Pages

Auto Car : Volkswagen Passat 2.0 TDI 140 SE

Volkswagen set the tone for the new Passat at a group preview event, which took place on the night before the Paris motor show opened last October. Through varying degrees of pizzazz involving flames, exploding crates and mock pit garages emerged Lamborghinis, Skodas, Bentleys and Audis.

Then, accompanied by nothing more than a puff of dry ice, out pootled the 'new' Passat. "Look," they said. "Waft your foot beneath the bootlid and it automatically opens." Woo.

See pics of the Volkswagen Passat in action :

The implication was pretty clear. This is a new Passat, rather than a new car; no shocks, no surprises. It'll do the same as it ever has: be a faithful companion to those people (and there are more than 15 million to date) who like the fuss-free way the Passat accompanies their life.

Volkswagen calls this Passat the seventh-generation car, but really it's a reskin (every panel save the roof is changed) and rework of the sixth-generation 2005 Passat. There are a few manufacturers who figure that modern platforms are so advanced now that, significant material changes aside (and they’ll eventually come, to reduce weight), honing will do.

Every major component has been tweaked on the Passat, though. Most significantly, suspension components are lighter and refinement is said to be improved.

What's it like?
Our test Passat, a 138bhp diesel, was pretty representative of a UK fleet car. We're pretty familiar with Volkswagen's 2.0-litre turbodiesel, but there are new engine mounts and the promise of smoother and quieter performance.

That's true enough, too. The Passat idles quietly and its drivetrain engages and operates with slickness and efficiency. The shift is light and positive, the controls deftly and progressively weighted.

It also rides. Whatever changes have been worked to the suspension have left the Passat supple yet well controlled, and with a surprisingly good level of crash-free bump absorption, so you hear but don't feel most imperfections.

Whatever you think of the Phaeton luxury car, it's pretty clear to me that the lessons haven’t been wasted. The Passat feels like a mature, sophisticated car, with a high-quality feel to the interior.

Both saloon and estate go on sale this month, and both are more or less the same size as before. In estate form, as tested, that means a sizeable 603-litre boot with the rear seats in place. They can be unlatched by switches just inside the tailgate, then dropped by nudging them forward with your long luggage. Handy.

What the Passat isn't, though, is particularly engaging. Your perch is wide, flat and firmly comfortable, the environment ergonomically sound and exceptionally quiet. There's a clock within easy read. All admirable qualities in a bedroom, but the enthusiast will be left wanting more from a car. The chassis proves capable at stopping, going and turning, but there's no reward to be gained by doing any of them.

Should I buy one?
Volkswagen has the ability and resources to make a car entertaining if it chooses to, so it's clear that it doesn't expect or want those qualities of the Passat. For those whose interest in driving extends no further than it being a requirement of their job or family life, the Passat will prove close to class leading. If it were the equivalent of a fridge or a lawn mower, we'd have no hesitation in recommending one.

The enthusiast, though, will also want something else in the garage to be satisfied.

VW Passat Estate 2.0 TDI SE BlueMotion
Price: £22,875; Top speed: 132mph; 0-62mph: 10.0sec; Economy: 61.4mpg (combined); CO2: 120g/km; Kerb weight: 1571kg; Engine: 4 cyls, 1968cc, turbodiesel; Installation: front, transverse, FWD; Power: 138bhp at 4200rpm; Torque: 236lb ft at 1750rpm; Gearbox: 6-spd manual

Saab 9-5 2.0 TTiD Aero

The range-topping 'TTiD' diesel version of Saab's 9-5 saloon, complete with a brand new twin-turbocharged 2.0-litre diesel engine that will also end up powering the Vauxhall Insignia.

And it's a car with plenty of weight on its shoulders. The various ranks of the UK motoring press have, as one, voiced the same criticisms of Saab's lesser 2.0-litre TiD '160' 9-5: there's no shortage of consensus that it's a car short on performance and refinement, and doesn't ride or handle well enough on UK roads.

To its credit, Saab has responded to these criticisms. This month it has beefed up standard 'Vector SE' specification on the 9-5 to include full leather seats and 18in wheels. More importantly, it has reappraised the chassis settings of the standard, passively damped 2.0-litre TiD 9-5 towards a more comfortable set-up with lower spring- and damper rates, softer anti-roll bars and more wheel travel.

And at the same time, Saab has launched this 187bhp, twin-turbocharged 'TTiD' 9-5. Not only does it get better performance than the 158bhp TiD, but it's offered with optional 'XWD' four-wheel drive. Which means that even the front-drivers get Saab's more sophisticated 'Linked H-arm' rear suspension.




What's it like?
This new engine is much more responsive than Saab's regular, single-turbo 2.0-litre diesel. Performance below 2500rpm is much less lethargic than it was in our road test car, and engine refinement below 3000rpm is better too. The 9-5 hardly feels fast, even in this guise, due to those tall gear ratios – but at least this one's quieter and easier to drive at normal crank speeds.

Our test car came in 'Aero' specification, on Sport suspension and 19in alloys: a verdict on the 9-5's new comfier standard chassis set-up will therefore have to wait.

However, with Saab's 'DriveSense' continuously active dampers and variable steering assistance systems onboard (neither of which our original road test car had fitted), this test car certainly rode and steered better than we expected. In 'Comfort' mode, its chassis soaked up urban bumps and troughs quite well. It also had better high-speed body control, and subjected occupants to less head toss, than our road test car.

Should I buy one?
This new version of the 9-5 proves that, if you dress it with the right options and go for the latest diesel engine, you can make this Saab meet most class standards. Spongy, lifeless steering and a determinedly unexciting chassis mean it'll never be a driver's car, but it's certainly spacious and attractive and – with this engine, at least - quite well-mannered.

Pricing levels almost at eye level with BMW's 525d and Mercedes' E250 CDi make this 9-5 a tough car to recommend, but it certainly shows that, after an inauspicious early showing, Saab's biggest saloon is now developing in the right direction.

Saab 9-5 2.0 TTiD Aero
Price: £32,165; Top speed: 143mph; 0-62mph: 8.5sec; Economy: 47.1mpg; Co2: 159g/km; Kerb weight: 1750kg (tbc); Engine type: 4cyls in line, 1956cc, twin turbodiesel; Power: 187bhp at 4000rpm; Torque: 295lb ft at 1750rpm; Gearbox: 6spd manual

Infiniti M Series 3.0d V6 S Premium

S-trim models get a different front-end look to distinguish them from regular versions

Distinctive upturned boot lip was designed to improve airflow and create zero lift at high speeds

Greater poise of S version comes at the price of an unsettled low-speed ride

On turn-in, tyhe M's steering is perhaps less fluid than that of a BMW 5-series or Mercedes E-class

In non-4WS models the Infiniti sometimes feels a little clumsy when it reaches its outer limits

For this car as tested, you'll have to pay £46,600

This 235bhp, 406lb ft 3.0-litre V6 is a mighty first effort (with a little help from Renault)

Wheel-mounted paddles are a good size and shape

It's an oversight that the 30mph and 70mph increments aren't highlighted on the speedo

Boot is smaller than those of M30d's rivals, and rear seats don't fold down

Cabin is snug and rival Jaguar XF for ambiance; driving position is hard to fault

Rear accommodation is acceptable for two adults, but headroom is restricted